From the Papers: “There will be a great demand for this book”

November 17, 2026

Image description: Collage of four images. Clockwise from top left: Title page of Miscellaneous Writings, with Mary Baker Eddy's portrait on the facing page. Cropped portion of a handwritten letter (Edward Bates to Mary Baker Eddy). Front cover of Miscellaneous Writings – grey pebbled leather, with a gold embossed "cross and crown" seal. Cropped portion of a handwritten letter (Alice Seward Brown to Mary Baker Eddy).

First edition of Miscellaneous Writings 1883–1896 (title page and outside cover); Edward P. Bates to Mary Baker Eddy, February 11, 1897, 019C.09.054; Alice Seward Brown to Eddy, February 13, 1897, 478.54.022.

Beginning with its first issue in April 1883, The Christian Science Journal1 contained articles by Mary Baker Eddy. She wrote to communicate or clarify important points regarding the teaching of Christian Science, answering questions like this one: “Must I have faith in Christian Science in order to be healed by it?” 2 Subsequent Journal issues included Eddy’s sermons, letters she wrote to The Mother Church and its branch churches, and other articles on timely topics.

In October 1895, Eddy’s student Edward P. Bates made a suggestion:

I have one request to make for your consideration, Viz. to take all your writings which are published in the Journal and bind them in book form. It seems to me they should be preserved as an entirity in this form…. Your letter and explanations in some of the early Journals are very helpful and you do not use the same language in any of your other writings.3

Thus the idea of Miscellaneous Writings 1883–1896 was born. It wasn’t until almost a year later, however, that she began in earnest to gather and revise her articles for publication. For this work Eddy engaged the assistance of Jessie C. H. Gorham. She had become dissatisfied with the work of James Henry Wiggin, her previous copy editor, who she felt took too many liberties in editing her work.4 Gorham had been working as an associate editor in various capacities at The Christian Science Publishing Society since 1889. They maintained an extensive correspondence over the following months, as Eddy worked to revise her articles for publication in book form.

In a handwritten note, Eddy outlined some details on the process they were to follow:

Miss Gorham copies them first and is responsible for their grammar. She does not add or diminish — only for that purpose — She sends each week to me VIA. Mrs. Sargent all her copies — and her bill.5

The note continued:

Mrs. Sargent will paste the clipping on a sheet of paper and hand them to Miss Gorham to copy and correct. Many perhaps will not need to be copied — only corrected on the margin of the page. 6

To ensure that the copies traveled safely, Eddy had her student Laura Sargent transport them between her home in Concord, New Hampshire, and Gorham’s office in Boston, rather than use the mail.7 They continued revising the process as they went along.8 Eddy wrote to Gorham in mid-October:

Your last copy shows me it is wise for me to look over the copy first and you afterwards. None but the author sees certain needs in the copy, and the less written by any other persons the better.9

As in other letters, she addressed specific aspects of the copy editing work:

Capitalize the synonyms of Deity that are nouns. Avoid as much as possible further capitalization. Divine Science always – and Science when it means C. S. capitalize. 10

Eddy’s standards, as well as the changes she asked for, could be challenging to meet; some of Gorham’s correspondence includes her own annotations, sharing her thoughts and perhaps documenting her perspective.11 Nonetheless, Eddy also showed appreciation for Gorham’s work: “Your last copies I have examined to-day and am delighted, delighted with them.”12 Evidently she and Gorham maintained a warm relationship, even during challenging periods, and she often referred to Gorham as her “loved literary Lassie,” as in a December 8, 1896, letter.13 Other variations on this term of endearment appear throughout their correspondence.

The volume was ready for publication in February 1897. Eddy had originally planned to title the book Repaid Pages, but that was changed in January.14 A brief announcement in the February 1897 Journal mentioned the upcoming volume:

By the 10th of February next, Mr. Armstrong, the publisher, expects to have in his hands ready for delivery, a new book of our Leader, the Rev. Mary Baker G. Eddy, entitled “Miscellaneous Writings.” It is a book of several hundred pages, and its mere mention by us is sufficient at this time.15

A fuller explanation of the new volume was included in the following issue.16

Miscellaneous Writings was dedicated “to Loyal Christian Scientists” and contained guidance on their daily practice of Eddy’s teachings. It also offered a sort of organizational history, capturing Eddy’s addresses, sermons, letters to The Mother Church and branch churches, answers to questions, and other counsel, all in one place, as had been suggested by Bates and much desired by others as well. In January 1897 Eddy wrote to Bates and her student Joseph Armstrong, who were both involved with the impending publication. “There will be a great demand for this book,” she predicted.17

Indeed, Miscellaneous Writings was warmly received. Christian Scientists sent letters to Eddy, expressing their gratitude. Daisette McKenzie, another student, wrote on February 13, 1897, “I have this moment received your last immeasurably precious gift to your children, and after reading the wonderful Dedication and Preface I find myself unable to read more until I have tried to express my gratitude to you.”18 Another letter of praise included these words:

Let me thank you with loving gratitude for the wonderful words of Life that have come to us this week in your “Miscellaneous Writings.” I feel now that you have opened wider the gate to Heaven, more Love is coming in upon us.19

Some Christian Scientists commented specifically on how useful the guidance shared in Miscellaneous Writings was to their practice. Carol Norton, who had studied privately with Eddy, wrote:

Words fail to express what I see in it of practical and vital value to the workers in the vineyard of Christian Science, and to those of us who have grown to see the great necessity of turning students and inquirers more and more to your writings.… Spiritually considered, the book appears to me as a great mountain of practical Christian Science, to be ascended through the ways and means, through the practical footsteps portrayed on every page of this most valuable addition to our literature. The book will save us, as field-workers, hours of time that we have been forced heretofore to give to explanation and answering vital questions about Christian Science.20

Bates had this to say in a February 11, 1897, letter:

I wish I might find words adequate to express all that I feel in receiving this last great gift from you. I consider it the most valuable Book ever published, since the Bible was issued with one exception only, ie.; “Science and Heath with Key to the Scriptures.” 21

Eddy also believed that this new book would offer practical guidance much needed in the field, and sent this letter to her students Ira and Flavia Knapp in February 1897:

If you have classes in C. S. engaged — teach them before March 1st as that is the date at which I have requested Students to stop for one year teaching, and let “Miscellaneous Writings” teach the minds of all who wish to learn C. S.…22

The March 1897 Journal soon followed with this notice:

The Christian Scientists in the United States and Canada are hereby enjoined not to teach a student Christian Science for one year, commencing on March 14th, 1897.

 

“Miscellaneous Writings” is calculated to prepare the minds of all true thinkers to understand the Christian Science Text-book more correctly than a student can. 23

Subsequent Journal issues included letters of gratitude and appreciation for the new book. Many readers, such as M. Bettie Bell, commented on the value of having all of Eddy’s additional writings in one place and the teachings they offered:

It has been a long-cherished hope to see those much-loved and studied articles grouped together. It is so artistically done, and each one touching on every, particular thing that all of us so needed. I find in each article such new thoughts that they all seemed fresh and rare. The book is an inspiration, and certainly you have given a course of lessons in “The Theology of Christian Science,” that will suit the need of every student.24

Bell had studied with Eddy for the first time in 1885, and although she appreciated the value of this collection, it was particularly important to newer students. In a way, it leveled the playing field between longtime students of Christian Science, who had access to Eddy’s classes and all back issues of The Christian Science Journal, and those who had become Christian Scientists more recently. Effie Andrews wrote along these lines:

One thing I almost envied “your students” for was their having the Series,25 and all the old Journals. I had much, but, longed for easier access to more. Again you have regarded the desire of your “students’ students,” and made us glad and thankful. Nothing can exceed its value to me; it is just what I wanted so much.26

Abbie Gardner Sharp echoed those sentiments:

With the valuable aid of “Miscellaneous Writings,”—Love’s latest gift to mankind, the Bible, and “Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures,” the sole Pastor and Impersonal Teacher, the need of every laborer in the Master’s vineyard is supplied. Now the dear ones who were not able to enter your Metaphysical College, or have not been taught the Principle and rules of Christian Science Mind-healing by your loyal students, can come in and sit with you at the Master’s table, and be fed,—not with a stone, but with the true bread of Life, Truth, and Love.27

Eddy’s collected writings after 1896 were published in The First Church of Christ, Scientist, and Miscellany.28 Both volumes continue to be published and offer valuable guidance for students of Christian Science today.

Please note: Quoted references in our “From the Papers” article series reflect the original documents. For this reason they may include spelling mistakes and edits made by the authors. In instances where a mark or edit is not easily represented in quoted text, an omission or insertion may be made silently.

  1. Until April 1885, the magazine was titled The Journal of Christian Science.
  2. Mary Baker Eddy, “Answers to Questions,” The Christian Science Journal, April 1883, 2.; Eddy, Miscellaneous Writings 1883–1896, 33.
  3. Edward P. Bates to Eddy, 19 October 1895, 019c.09.041.
  4. See Eddy to Jessie C. H. Gorham, 8 December 1896, L07989.
  5. Eddy to Gorham, September 1896, L10541.
  6. Eddy to Gorham, September 1896, L10541.
  7. In correspondence, Eddy often referred to Sargent as “my pigeon” and even gifted her a small pigeon trinket after the work on Miscellaneous Writings 1883-1896 was complete. See: https://www.marybakereddylibrary.org/research/an-ivory-pigeon-for-eddys-bright-bearer-of-messages/
  8. See for example, Eddy to Gorham, 15 October 1896, L07979.
  9. Eddy to Gorham, 18 October 1896, L07980.
  10. Eddy to Gorham, 18 October 1896, L07980.
  11. See for example, Eddy to Gorham, 18 November 1896, L07986.
  12. Eddy to Gorham, 8 December 1896, L07989.
  13. Eddy to Gorham, 8 December 1896, L07989.
  14. Eddy to Gorham, 6 January 1897, L07998.
  15. “A New Book by Mrs. Eddy,” The Christian Science Journal, February 1897, 556.
  16. See “The New Book,” Journal, March 1897, 622–624.
  17. Eddy to Joseph Armstrong and Bates, 9 January, 1897, L02808.
  18. Daisette D. S. McKenzie to Eddy, 13 February 1897, 013d.08.015.
  19. Alice S. Brown to Eddy, 13 February 1897, 478.54.022.
  20. Carol Norton to Eddy, 14 February 1897, 032b.12.030.
  21. Bates to Eddy, 11 February 1897, 019c.09.054.
  22. Eddy to Ira O. Knapp and Flavia Stickney Knapp, 14 February 1897, L04230.
  23. Eddy, “Notice,” Journal, March 1897, 575.
  24. M. Bettie Bell, “Letters to Mrs. Eddy,” Journal, April 1897, 40.
  25. This refers to the Christian Science Series, published from 1889–1891 by The Christian Science Publishing Society.
  26. Effie Andrews, “Letters to Mrs. Eddy,” Journal, April 1897, 39.
  27. Abbie Gardner Sharp, “Letters to Mrs. Eddy,” Journal, May 1897, 101.
  28. Although Eddy decided the book’s content, Miscellany was not published until 1913, almost three years after her passing.